Fundraising and systemic injustice

Imagine a healthcare charity. Picture the CEO. I saw one on TV recently, it was a white man. Now picture the person who cleans the floors.  Did you picture a racialized woman?  What’s the different in their wages?  The front-line healthcare worker might not be able to afford healthcare herself.

Now imagine fundraising for such a charity. It’s not a stretch, many of us are in exactly that situation.  Fundraisers want to make the world a better place. Does that mean pursuing justice?  Does it mean raising as much money as possible, regardless of how?

In her book, a 40-Day Journey with Kathleen Norris, she writes:

We are seeking the tribal, anything with strong communal values and traditions. But all too often we’re trying to do it on our own, as individuals. That is the tradition of middle-class America: a belief in individual accomplishment so strong that it favors exploitation over stewardship, mobility over stability.

The “exploitation over stewardship” part hit me hard. Stewardship means taking care of the world entrusted to us, loving our neighbours, living generously as children of a generous God.

I’m tempted to reduce stewardship to individual niceness when social justice is what is required. Aren’t fundraisers supposed to be nice? I’m tempted to reduce stewardship to efficiency when justice is what is required. Aren’t fundraisers supposed to raise lots of money?

To favor stewardship over exploitation will require active opposition to systemic racism. Undertaking anti-Black racism training is not a distraction from a charity’s core mission, it is favoring stewardship over exploitation.

A charity might ‘accomplish’ more by taking advantage of volunteers and low-paid staff. A charity might achieve higher fundraising targets by burning through staff. Is that stewardship? No, it’s exploitation masquerading as efficiency, which circles right back to the original quote from Kathleen Norris.

A friend recently shared the Nice White Parents podcast from the New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/23/podcasts/nice-white-parents-serial.html

My friend was horrified to hear how major donor fundraising undertaken by white parents – gala, silent auction with luxury goods – sounded through the ears of brown and Black parents at the school. The white parents were ‘successful’ fundraisers who raised lots of money – for their kids. Their fundraising was efficient, but it wasn’t just.

I have more questions than answers. I’m a hypocrite enmeshed in an unjust system. I’ve been reading a lot – most recently Defiant by Kelley Nikondeha, which looks at women in Exodus. What gives me hope is working together with others. Love casts out fear – an active love, love that won’t settle for less than justice. A slow, determined, inefficient love. A love that encompasses both the CEO and the cleaner, the fundraiser and the donor, and a love which stewards them all as part of the charity’s mission.